close

What Were They Thinking? The Monopoly Game Show

Contestants on the Monopoly television game show set

Some ideas sound so good that you wonder how anyone could screw them up. Then you watch the finished product and get your answer. For me, the Monopoly game show was one of those ideas.

I remember the promotion and the excitement. Monopoly was a game everyone knew. We grew up buying properties, collecting rent, building hotels, and hoping someone would land on Boardwalk when we owned it. There was strategy, luck, negotiation, and the possibility that a friendly family game would end with someone refusing to speak to someone else. That was entertainment already.

Then came the television version.

The Monopoly game show aired on ABC in the summer of 1990, produced by Merv Griffin and hosted by Mike Reilly. With Griffin’s success with Wheel of Fortune and Jeopardy!, you would think this was in good hands. Instead, we got contestants answering crossword-style clues to acquire properties. Somehow, a game about buying real estate and bankrupting your opponents became a quiz show wearing a Monopoly costume.

I thought it was horrible. The familiar property names and board couldn’t make up for the fact that it didn’t feel like the game I loved. Where was the wheeling and dealing? Where was the satisfaction of squeezing rent out of someone who had just laughed at your financial problems?

Obviously, you couldn’t televise an entire family Monopoly game in thirty minutes. Some of those games lasted longer than a presidential administration. But adapting something requires understanding why people enjoy it.

The show lasted just one summer. That didn’t surprise me.

A recognizable name can get people to watch once. It can’t make them enjoy what they’re watching. If you’re going to borrow the Monopoly name, bring along the fun. Otherwise, you’ve passed Go and collected an audience that won’t be coming back.

Story Page