When it comes to entertainment, there are some choices to make on what was better, so this is my two cents.
Godfather I vs II: The Godfather, except Part II comes close.
Van Halen with Roth vs. Hagar: David Lee Roth (does anyone prefer Gary Cherone?)
Superman I vs II: II, it has General Zod.
The two Darrens: Dick York vs Dick Sargent: York, by a mile. He had the face of an annoyed mortal husband.
Less Filling vs Tastes Great: Miller Lite is awful, but always pick beer on taste.
Henry Blake vs. Colonel Potter: Henry Blake.
Trapper John vs BJ: Trapper John.
Diane vs. Rebecca on Cheers: Rebecca.
Coke vs. Pepsi: Coke, but Diet Pepsi is far better than Diet Coke.
McDonald’s vs. Burger King: I lived behind one in Brooklyn, so I say Burger King.
Chicago vs. New York Pizza: I’m from Brooklyn do you have to ask?